Jaycee Dugard: An American Slave

Roger Porter

June 4, 2011

               Yesterday in El Dorado superior court in Placerville, CA Phillip Garrido was given life in prison and his wife Nancy was given 36 years for the kidnapping and sexual enslavement of Jaycee Dugard. Although the case received international media attention when it first broke in 2009 the graphic details of the abuse suffered by Jaycee Dugard, who was kidnapped at the age of 11 and held captive for 19 years, had not been made public until today.

                When I read about it in the paper I couldn’t help but to compare it to the autobiography of Harriet Jacobs who was born into slavery. She wrote the slave narrative under a pseudonym and it is called Linda Brent, Incidents in the Life of a Slave Girl. In the book Jacobs recalls confining herself to a small garret for several years to escape the sexual advances of her philandering owner. Similarly Dugard lived in a tent in the backyard of the Garrido’s property for 19 years until she was rescued, but unfortunately for Dugard she could not escape the advances of her captor. Dugard was raped repeatedly and had two children by Phillip Garrido.

                The element of the story that most reminded me of something from the antebellum South was that Jaycee had to go by another name while in captivity. Phillip Garrido called her Snoopy and eventually she chose the name Alissa for herself. It was this kind of resocialization that led Dugard to believe that she was living a normal life and that the people who had stolen her off the street really loved her, therefore she refused to run away even when Phillip Garrido went to prison for a parole violation. Dugard said that she never ran away because if she did she wouldn’t know how to take care of herself or how to make money. She worried that her two girls would starve to death.

                I once read in an article that when West Africans were marched from the inlands of Africa to the slave fortresses on the coast in preparation for the brutal middle-passage, everyone would be chained or bound together except the women with very small children. The reason being that the possibility of a woman running away with a baby in her arms was very low and if she did try to run then she wouldn’t get far; thus the baby in itself served as a form of shackles.

                The Jaycee Dugard case is a reminder that slavery is not merely the physical ownership of a human being but it is mental control as well. Once a person convinces another person that they cannot take care of themselves then they have effectively transformed that individual into a submissive being. Just like the pimp does the prostitute, like the missionary does the native, like the master does the slave, and like the police do the poor.

              The Jaycee Dugard story is woefully sad and I pray that she will have the ability to rise up from slavery like my ancestors did.

3 thoughts on “Jaycee Dugard: An American Slave

  1. Very astute comparison; love this..

  2. The big difference to remember here when comparing Jaycee Dugard and black slaves in the old south is that slavery was legal at that time. A runaway slave was committing a crime and both citizens and law enforcement were constantly vigilant to recapture them. Jaycee Dugard could have walked out the door almost any time in the last 12 years she was with Garrido. All she had to do was tell any citizen or police officer who she was. She could also have easily emailed anyone in the world. For whatever reason, (drugs, sex, love), she stayed with him because she wanted to. She also fought longer and harder to keep her identity and their relationship a secret from the authorities.

    “Dugard said that she never ran away because if she did she wouldn’t know how to take care of herself or how to make money.”

    This statement is hilarious. She “didn’t know how to make money” but she skillfully parlayed that $20 million “award” into $200 million +.

    • Slavery is very complex. Especially when you analyze the mental aspects of it all. There were many black slaves who loved their white masters and not only refused to run away but snitched on other slaves who plotted takeovers (see Denmark Vessey). There are also many slaves who profited financially from there enslavement (see slave narratives).
      I do agree with you on the major difference between Duggard and black slaves but there are many parallels and it is rather striking.
      Thanks for reading.

Leave a Reply to YB Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.